Amazon.com Widgets

« Links With Your Coffee - Thursday | Main | Interview with Daniel Dennett BBC4 »

Supreme Torture





Comments

"has anybody referred to torture as punishemnt?"

shit; this longer comment is the equivalent of Cheney's "So?"

except that Scalia will be in position long after Cheney's gone.

Arrrrgh!

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/7376741.stm - so far I have only found this article on the BBC site.

"If I'm the president, we will attack Iran... we would be able to totally obliterate them," she told TV network ABC.

except that Scalia will be in position long after Cheney's gone.

And yet there remains a high percentage of Hillary Clinton supporters and a small percentagage of Obama supporters who would rather vote for John McCain or some third-party candidate if their chosen candidate is not elected and allow yet another right-winger get appointed to the Supreme Court..

sigh..

If I'm the president, we will attack Iran... we would be able to totally obliterate them," she told TV network ABC.

Yep, if HIllary gets elected, she be elected on the backs of the "Bubbas" and they'll expect her to represent their views.

She'll get us into a war with Iran and she'll outlaw flag burning.

Last month Justice Antonin Scalia was politely quizzed by Norman Pearlstine, the outgoing Time Inc. editor in chief. The event, held in Time Warner's New York headquarters, was supposedly off the record, but so much of it has already been reported that it will not hurt to add Scalia's views on flag burning. He explained why it was constitutionally protected speech. It's a pity Hillary Clinton was not there to hear him.

so Hillary Clinton is more conservative than Scalia on this issue.

And hell, she didn't just vote for the ammendment, she helped to introduce it!

Along with Sen. Robert Bennett, a Utah Republican, she has introduced a bill that would make flag burning illegal.

user-pic

This guy, along with four other members of the Supreme Court, belongs to an organization that is essentially a front for child rapists.

His views on torture are about what one should expect.

The good news is, he's older than he looks: he's 72. Alito, alas, is only 58.

"Get over it" was all he had to say about one of the most significant Supreme Court cases of this era? Torture is OK because it´s not punishment?

I don´t get it. They said Scalia was first in his class, got all As, etc. yet he seems like a dumb fuck to this less -than-straight-A student. The really, really bad part is that Thomas is even more of a right-wing moron.

Except, Leftbanker, he is very intelligent and his statement refers to legal interpretation of the issue, which you choose to ignore simply based on your ideological orientation. If there is to be any meaningful debate on any issue left and right disagree on, underestimating your opponents intelligence and demeaning them in light of your own ignorance is hardly the right approach. Scalia might be a fence jumper, when he voted liberal on Gonzales v. Reich, but he is hardly an idiot.

Torture is OK because it´s not punishment?

Yeah, for those keeping score, Torture is punishment for not cooperating.

Scalia thinks he is smart.

I agree with Scalia. Interrogative torture is not punishment, it's a means to an end, not an end in itself. It's silly to say otherwise.

user-pic

While his comment about torture did make me laugh out loud because the way it was phrased seemingly contradicted itself, he's actually right in legal terms. "Cruel and unusual punishment" refers to just that - the punishments handed out as sentences. That's why people aren't stoned to death by the state today as a form of capital punishment.

Not to say that torture is right or justified, but if we're looking to show that it's illegal the term "cruel and unusual punishment" isn't the way to go.

Not to say that torture is right or justified, but if we're looking to show that it's illegal the term "cruel and unusual punishment" isn't the way to go.

It is punishment, just punishment executed without a trail. A right to trial is the primary right being violated by domestic torture.

But internationally it isn't the US constitution that is being violated. Its the Geneva conventions.

I don't know the whole comment, but Scalia is right that torture in interrogations is not related to the 8th amendment protection against cruel and unusual punishment. Punishment is a remedy for a crime, whereas torture in interrogations is aimed at getting information.

In the case of Abu Ghraib torture is a war crime; in the case of police torture it's simply aggravated assault.

"It is punishment, just punishment executed without a trail. A right to trial is the primary right being violated by domestic torture."

I still don't think this is a good way to look at it, because you're looking at offending officers as agents of the state which legitimately punishes crime. But torture (in interrogations) is more than a lack of due process and a violation of the proper scope of punishment, it is itself a crime against the person, for which all the offending officers and their complicit superiors are guilty.

Re: "Bush v. Gore"

This is always what Scalia says about it. He's been saying "get over it" for a long time. He's never given a legal defense of the opinion. Sandra day O'Connor's best attempt at a defense was "Bush ended up winning in the best estimates of the Florida vote anyway". She, too, had no legal argument. It's really outrageous.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.You may use Markdown or HTML in your comments if you include a URL and don't use HTML encoding please enclose it in less than and greater than signs as in <url>)

Navigation

Support This Site


support OGM

powells.gif


advertise_liberally.gif

Google Ads


Onegoodmove Picks

Books I'm currently reading, and have recently read.



All purchases made at Amazon through these links contribute to support this site. Thanks for your help.


MarsEdit: Powerful Blog Authoring Made Simple.

Advertise Liberally Blogroll

All Spin Zone
AMERICAblog
AmericanStreet
ArchPundit
BAGNewsnotes
The Bilerico Project
BlogACTIVE
BluegrassReport
Bluegrass Roots
Blue Indiana
BlueJersey
Blue Mass.Group
BlueOregon
BlueNC
Brendan Calling
BRAD Blog
Buckeye State Blog
Chris Floyd
Clay Cane
Calitics
CliffSchecter
ConfinedSpace
culturekitchen
David Corn
Dem Bloggers
Democrats.com
Deride and Conquer
Democratic Underground
Digby
DovBear
Drudge Retort
Ed Cone
ePluribis Media
Eschaton
Ezra Klein
Feministe
Firedoglake
Fired Up
First Draft
Frameshop
GreenMountain Daily
Greg Palast
Hoffmania
Horse's Ass
Hughes for America
In Search of Utopia
Is That Legal?
Jesus' General
Jon Swift
Keystone Politics
Kick! Making PoliticsFun
KnoxViews
Lawyers, Guns and Money
Left Coaster
Left in the West
Liberal Avenger
Liberal Oasis
Loaded Orygun
MaxSpeak
Media Girl
Michigan Liberal
MinnesotaCampaign Report
Minnesota Monitor
My Left Nutmeg
My Two Sense
Nathan Newman
Needlenose
Nevada Today
News Dissector
News Hounds
Nitpicker
Oliver Willis
onegoodmove
PageOneQ
Pam's House Blend
Pandagon
PinkDome
Politics1
PoliticalAnimal
Political Wire
Poor Man Institute
Prairie State Blue
Progressive Historians
Raising Kaine
Raw Story
Reno Discontent
Republic of T
Rhode Island's Future
Rochester Turning
Rocky Mountain Report
Rod 2.0
Rude Pundit
Sadly, No!
Satirical Political Report
Shakesville
SirotaBlog
SistersTalk
Slacktivist
SmirkingChimp
SquareState
Suburban Guerrilla
Swing State Project
Talking Points Memo
Tapped
Tattered Coat
The Albany Project
The Blue State
The Carpetbagger Report
The Democratic Daily
The Hollywood Liberal
The Talent Show
This Modern World
Town Called Dobson
Wampum
WashBlog
Watching the Watchers
West Virginia Blue
Young Philly Politics
Young Turks

Contact


Commenting Policy

note: non-authenticated comments are moderated, you can avoid the delay by registering.

Random Quotation

Recent Comments

Zaphod for President on:
Shut Up, Mark Sanford

Norm on:
Inertia

jillbryant2003 on:
Links With Your Coffee - Friday

jonathan becker on:
Homeopathic A & E

Jay on:
Oliver Sacks

redizdead on:
Links With Your Coffee - Saturday

jonathan becker on:
Links With Your Coffee - Thursday

Andyo on:
Franken Has Won

George Orwell on:
The Story of King David Mark

Andyo on:
God Talk

Cynthia on:
Zicam Recall

c3o on:
I Read The News Today

articulett on:
Zinger

jonathan becker on:
Larry David

macromayhem on:
Lindsay Graham a Douchebag

Individual Archives

Monthly Archives

scarlet_A.png
Get WidgetThe Body CountJenny McCarthy Body Count

Powered by Movable Type Pro

Copyright © 2002-2009 Norman Jenson